Pixe Sukola's Feed

Pixe Sukola
10-09-2018 at 11:29 AM
12 Comments
Rate this Entry

Adjudication Deal

Following on the steps of Paul Kernz, I'll also make a deal with other users.

I will adjudicate 2 of your submissions for every vote on any of my Wii Virtual Console specially, or my other submissions. Note: I'm not encouraging blind vote, but legit adjudication. (Metropolis Street Racer excluded, those already pass fast enough.)

I think this motivates members to adjudicate a little more, moves the queue along and helps pass scores faster, who doesn't enjoy that? This idea altho' unorthodox and weird, I think it is ultimately benefitial.


Fighting Games

Samurai Shodown https://www.twingalaxies.com/showthread.php/193170

Samurai Shodown 2 https://www.twingalaxies.com/showthread.php/193147

Street Fighter II https://www.twingalaxies.com/showthread.php/193144


Platforms

Super Mario Bros. https://www.twingalaxies.com/showthread.php/193548


Racing

Mario Kart 64

https://www.twingalaxies.com/showthread.php/193015

https://www.twingalaxies.com/showthread.php/193012

https://www.twingalaxies.com/showthread.php/193141

https://www.twingalaxies.com/showthread.php/193142



ThanksDesidious thanked this post
LikesSnowflake, EVN, kernzyp liked this post
Comments
  1. TheHappywheels1's Avatar

    I mean, I would do anyway, but I think you've already adjudicated all of my submissions xD

    Anyway, i'll check them out!

    ThanksPixe Sukola thanked this post
  2. Tristen Geren's Avatar

    I only got two submissions, but I'll take a look at as many of yours as I can. The Black Ops III GWR track I really want to push through. Its under the username "Tristen Geren and Matt Pehl" since its a two-person record.

    LikesPixe Sukola liked this post
  3. Snowflake's Avatar

    I think this is fine and completley in spirit with the system. We dont have refs, we adjudicate each other. If you want your records adjudciated its only fair you adjudicate others.

    I would suggest though, if this is about to become a thing, that we clariy the votes dont have to be accept to ensure there is no collusion. You know, even if someone rejects your score, thats still a vote and I trust you'll vote ontheir stuff fairly? Likewise even if someone accepts your score, you're not promising to accept theirs you're just promising to vote fairly on theirs, possibly rejecting if warranted. The offer also has to be open to all so that we're not just picking adjudicators who will rule in our favor.

    I didnt bring this up before as I'm sure both you and kernzy mean it this way and with good faith. But as this sort of offer becomes more common it might be good toexpliclyty mention such things to prevent collusion -- or even the appearance of collusion.

  4. Pixe Sukola's Avatar

    Quote Originally Posted by Snowflake

    I think this is fine and completley in spirit with the system. We dont have refs, we adjudicate each other. If you want your records adjudciated its only fair you adjudicate others.

    I would suggest though, if this is about to become a thing, that we clariy the votes dont have to be accept to ensure there is no collusion. You know, even if someone rejects your score, thats still a vote and I trust you'll vote ontheir stuff fairly? Likewise even if someone accepts your score, you're not promising to accept theirs you're just promising to vote fairly on theirs, possibly rejecting if warranted. The offer also has to be open to all so that we're not just picking adjudicators who will rule in our favor.

    I didnt bring this up before as I'm sure both you and kernzy mean it this way and with good faith. But as this sort of offer becomes more common it might be good toexpliclyty mention such things to prevent collusion -- or even the appearance of collusion.


    Completely agree.


    That's why I specified that I'm not encouraging blind voting, but legit adjudication, meaning I will accept YES and NO votes equally and from any user.

    LikesSnowflake liked this post
  5. Pixe Sukola's Avatar

    Quote Originally Posted by TheHappywheels1

    I mean, I would do anyway, but I think you've already adjudicated all of my submissions xD

    Anyway, i'll check them out!


    That's right I've adjudicated your 4 submissions.


    If anyone is interested in some quick, easy SP and cred, Christopher has 3 easy rejects, they are in the console leaderboard and should have been submitted to the PC one.


    https://www.twingalaxies.com/thehappywheels1/rankings#scores

    ThanksHugDD thanked this post
  6. Pixe Sukola's Avatar

    Quote Originally Posted by Tristen Geren

    I only got two submissions, but I'll take a look at as many of yours as I can. The Black Ops III GWR track I really want to push through. Its under the username "Tristen Geren and Matt Pehl" since its a two-person record.


    great, just make sure to leave a comment on the submission you adjudicate and I will check both of yours.

  7. GibGirl's Avatar

    I'll tweak this deal. For every one of yours, adjudicate only one of mine, but starting with the oldest, and add a comment too. :)

    LikesPixe Sukola liked this post
  8. Pixe Sukola's Avatar

    Quote Originally Posted by GibGirl

    I'll tweak this deal. For every one of yours, adjudicate only one of mine, but starting with the oldest, and add a comment too. :)


    I love it!


    accepted :)

    ThanksGibGirl thanked this post
  9. Desidious's Avatar

    I've taken the liberty to adjudicate all of your Vita games. I'll work on your other racers probably tomorrow and Thursday. I know, I usually don't comment accepted on stuff but I'll try to make it more of a habit.

    ThanksPixe Sukola thanked this post
    LikesPixe Sukola liked this post
  10. Pixe Sukola's Avatar

    Quote Originally Posted by Desidious

    I've taken the liberty to adjudicate all of your Vita games. I'll work on your other racers probably tomorrow and Thursday. I know, I usually don't comment accepted on stuff but I'll try to make it more of a habit.


    I leave comments on the submissions I adjudicate for several reasons.


    1. Let the player know somebody looked at his score and they probably wll return the favor

    2. Let other players know the submission is ok, or not, making it easier for others to check.

    3. A comment moves the submission to the top of the queue, allowing for others to see it easily.

    4. (in this case) Lets me know who adjudicated, and I can adjudicate theirs.

    LikesGibGirl, onlyinajeep liked this post
  11. GibGirl's Avatar

    Quote Originally Posted by Pixe Sukola

    3. A comment moves the submission to the top of the queue, allowing for others to see it easily.


    This is a big part of my incentive for commenting - and I really try to comment in a way that actually further encourages discussion. Discussion keeps the submission at the front and makes it more likely it resolves quickly. Along with all the other good benefits that come out of discussion (community building, sharing knowledge, etc).



    LikesPixe Sukola liked this post
  12. Desidious's Avatar

    I try not to just put "accept". Usually I'll make a comment that doesn't even show what I voted on most cases. I do this to eliminate people trying to LEECH off my valid adjudication by blindly voting after seeing someone with 10k+ cred making a public announcement of what they voted.

Join us